As a freshman, Toni came in and started al 7 games for the Arizona doftball team. That season, and won the league title. Toni was named the Pac- 10 Newcomer of the Year and earned All-College World Seies and first team All-America honors. Toni became an All-Pac 10 conference player every year she played and earned a second first team All-America honor in 2001. She led the Wildcats to their 2001 National Championshp and at the time of her induction, was in the NCAA top 5 record books for home runs for a season (25) and career RBI's (245). Toni was also listed in the UA softball record books in ten different categories when she was inducted into The University of Arizona Sports Hall of Fame in 2006. Toni graduated with her degree in political science and spent time on the USA Elite team and was a member of the Arizona Heat in the National Pro Fast Pitch league.